Quality Monitoring Program Resources  


Psychotropic Medication Use


Overview | Resident Evaluation | Care Planning | Quality Improvement | Medication Topics | Related Tags | DADS Presentations | Additional Resources | Bibliography | Reviewers | Feedback

This is a preliminary rather than a completed best practice framework.  

Top of Page Overview

The DADS Quality Assurance and Improvement vision for psychotropic drug use in LTC is

Using psychoactive medications only for appropriate clinical indications and with proper monitoring.

Definitions and Scope

Although the term psychotropics has a variety of meanings made explicit in state and federal statutes, the term here is used more narrowly to refer to three classes of agents: antipsychotics, anxiolytics and sedative/hypnotic drugs. Drug classes such as antidepressants, anticonvulsants, anti-parkinsonian agents and others used in the management of other psychiatric and neurological conditions are addressed in illness-specific frameworks. The general principles of appropriate psychotropic drug use are discussed in this page while more specific information is presented in medication topic pages.

Behavioral and psychological symptoms are common among nursing home residents, with a prevalence as high as 82% among those with cognitive impairment.[1] Many nursing home residents also experience sleep disturbances.[2] In Texas LTC facilities, nonpsychotic behavioral symptoms and sleep disturbances are often managed inappropriately with psychotropic medications. These agents cause a greater incidence of adverse events in the elderly.[2] Successful non-drug therapy for these symptoms can decrease adverse drug effects, improve resident outcomes, and reduce health care costs.

A 2003 DADS review of the medication administration records of Texas nursing facility residents 65 years and older found that 28.9% of residents had taken an antipsychotic in the preceding week, 18.7% had taken an anti-anxiety medication, and 8.5% had taken a sedative/hypnotic. Texas residents were prescribed these medications at rates 1.2, 1.7 and 3.0 times greater than the corresponding national averages. Among residents taking antipsychotic medications, 37.5% had no clinical indication that met widely accepted criteria (e.g., OBRA-87) for appropriate use.[13] In the absence of persuasive evidence that Texas nursing facility residents have greater needs for psychotropic medications than LTC residents elsewhere in the United States, there is reason for concern regarding the appropriateness of psychotropic medication use in Texas LTC.

Top of Page Resident Evaluation

Evaluation prior to the reduction or discontinuation of psychotropic medication should include the following:

Clear Identification and Understanding of the Clinical Problems, Goals, and Risks

Residents on more than one psychotropic drug, residents whose symptoms have been controlled for 30 days or more, and those who experience side effects are candidates for medication reduction or discontinuation. For these residents, ask the following questions (these apply to all antipsychotic, anti-anxiety, and sedative/hynotic drugs):

  • Why were psychotropic drugs prescribed?
  • Was a specific clinical condition diagnosed and documented in the clinical record?
  • Were relevant non-pharmacological interventions initiated prior to prescribing a psychotropic agent?
  • Is psychotropic therapy appropriate for this condition?
  • Has informed consent been obtained from the resident and/or family? Make sure the informed consent includes the following required information:
    • Specific condition to be treated;
    • Beneficial effects on that condition expected from the medication?
    • Probable clinically significant side effects (common side effects/adverse reactions) and risks associated with the medication, as reported in widely available pharmacy databases or the manufacturer's package insert; and
    • Proposed course of the medication.
  • What are the measurable goals of the prescribed therapy? (For example, "The resident will wash his hands no more than ten times a day. There will be healing of cracked, bleeding hand lesions.")
  • Are those goals being monitored? Has therapy been titrated in response to therapeutic monitoring?
  • Are side effects being monitored? Has therapy been titrated or changed in response to side effect monitoring?


Trial and Evaluation of Reduction or Discontinuation of Therapy

Identifying a mood or behavioral symptom should not lead directly to the prescribing of psychotropic medications without a trial of non-pharmacological management. The exceptions to this statement are situations in which most clinical evidence shows that psychotropic therapy is necessary to manage the disorder (e.g., schizophrenia and related psychoses). Similarly, to proceed directly from identifying residents taking psychotropic medications to the discontinuation of those medications is not best practice. In general, stepwise medication reduction at certain time intervals (e.g., every seven days) is recommended.[3] Residents should be carefully evaluated at each interval for the emergence of side effects or new symptoms unresponsive to non-pharmacological therapy, which should be implemented during, as well as after, psychotropic drug reduction or discontinuation.

If dose reduction is ended due to an adverse event (e.g., the reemergence of symptoms that cannot be controlled without medication), this should be documented in the resident's chart. It is important to note that research has repeatedly demonstrated that the discontinuation of antipsychotics [4,5,6,7,8] and benzodiazepines [4,8] in nursing home residents is often successful. Discontinuation of pharmacological therapy is not necessarily associated with an increase in behavioral symptoms [5,6,8] or an increased use of physical restraints.[5,7]

Top of Page Structured Resident Assessment and Care Planning

Not every resident who is on psychotropic therapy will be a candidate for reduction or discontinuation of psychotropic therapy. Use the following DADS Quality Monitoring structured resident assessments to assess the appropriateness of psychotropic drug use and to identify residents who are candidates for withdrawal of the following psychotropic drugs classes:

Validated tools for illness screening and symptom rating are also available. These scales are supplements to rather than substitutes for resident assessment and a detailed recording of symptoms. Use scales that are specific to the psychiatric condition.

Care Planning

For care planning strategies, refer to each specific topic.

Top of Page Practical Guide to Quality Improvement

Key Components for Successful Psychotropic Drug Reduction Programs

Successful psychotropic drug reduction initiatives requires cooperation from staff and family members.[4,5,6,7,12] Include the following structural and process elements in your initiatives (these apply to all of antipsychotic, anti-anxiety, and sedative and hypnotic drugs unless otherwise stated):

  • Psychotropic drug reduction training for all staff members.
  • Geriatric psychopharmacology training for medical staff.
  • Psychotropic drug reduction education for family members.
  • Frequent reevaluation of all residents who remain on psychotropic drug therapy.

Part I. Education

  1. Assess the factors that influence the prescribing of psychotropic drugs in your facility.
  2. Use DADS Joint Training and QMWeb resources to provide staff and family education on psychotropic drug reduction.
  3. Educate staff and family members on the use of non-pharmacological alternatives for behavioral symptoms, sleep complaints and situational anxiety.
  4. Provide periodic training in strategies to manage behavioral symptoms in residents with dementia.
  5. Develop a facility plan for reducing the use of psychotropic medications, and present it to staff, family and resident council.
  6. Work with DADS Pharmacist Quality Monitors to pilot, evaluate and refine your psychotropic drug reduction program.

Part II. Discontinue Unnecessary Psychotropic Medications

  1. Begin with your facility's Quality Indicator report to identify residents who are taking antipsychotics in the absence of a psychotic disorder (QI-19) and residents who are taking anti-anxiety and/or hypnotic medications (QI-20).
  2. Review all medication administration records in order to identify additional residents on antipsychotics, hypnotics and anti-anxiety medications not yet noted in MDS assessments.
  3. Use a structured assessment instrument to evaluate each of these residents for the appropriateness of psychotropic drug use. Leave the completed assessment(s) on the chart for future reference.
  4. Schedule periodic psychotropic drug use reassessment for every resident who continues on treatment.
  5. For residents in whom psychotropic medications were begun without a trial of non-pharmacological interventions or begun for particular symptoms, address the following:
    1. What is the psychiatric diagnosis? Does it meet DSM-IV criteria?
    2. Do the symptoms represent a danger to the resident or others?
    3. Are there environmental triggers for these symptoms?
    4. Are there treatable medical causes such as pain for these symptoms?
    5. Have the symptoms worsened when the medication was tapered or discontinued?
  6. Implement a psychotropic drug reduction plan.
    1. Involve the resident's family in the design of the plan.
    2. Provide family education on the risks of psychotropic drug use, the expected negative effects of continued psychotropic drug use, and the anticipated benefits of psychotropic drug reduction.
    3. Closely monitor the resident for adverse effects of dose reduction.
    4. Adjust the pace of dose tapering to minimize adverse effects.
    5. Carefully document the changes in the symptoms of residents in whom psychotropic drug reduction or discontinuation is not successful.
  7. Review each chart to identify instances in which care plans and actual care giving are not congruent.

Part III. Prevent the Unnecessary Initiation of Psychotropic Medications

  1. Require the use of structured assessment for psychotropic drug use before these medications can be ordered.
  2. Utilize a formal facility process to care plan, implement and evaluate the use of behavioral interventions and environmental modifications for symptoms that may respond to non-pharmacological therapy.
  3. Use a formal review process to develop care plan alternatives when structured assessment shows that psychotropic drug use is not necessary.

Part IV. Monitor Therapy for Benefits and Side Effects

Use a process of on-going structured assessment to ensure all of the following:

  1. That there is monitoring for the known side effects of the psychotropic medication(s).
  2. That there is monitoring of each psychotropic medication's effects regarding the therapeutic goals. For example, monitoring of the sleeping patterns of residents taking hypnotics.
  3. That psychotropic medications are considered as possible causes of unexpected adverse events
  4. That the family and prescribing physician are notified of significant changes in the resident's condition that may be related to psychotropic medications.
  5. That the physician responds to notifications concerning adverse events potentially related to psychotropic medications.

Top of Page Medication Topics


Top of Page Related Licensure and Certification Tags

The following deficiencies may be cited for failure to use psychotropic medications appropriately. Tags that might be cited as evidence that necessary services were not provided to a resident with psychiatric symptoms are also listed. The deficiency list is representative rather than exhaustive.

Program Licensure Tags (State) Certification Tags (Federal)
Nursing Facilities
19.403 (g) F155 Right to refuse treatment
19.403 (k)(1)(B) F157 Notification for changes in mental status
19.502 (f) F203 Advocacy for the mentally ill
19.601 (a) F222 Drugs used for discipline or staff convenience
19.601 (c) F226 Training for behavioral interventions
19.701 F240 Quality of life
19.703 (a) F250 Alternatives to drug therapy
19.802 (a)(1)(2) F279 Comprehensive care planning
19.801 (7) F278 Accuracy of assessment
19.801 (2)(A)(B) F272 Comprehensive assessment
19.1601 (1)(A)(B) F353 Adequate staff
19.901 (12)(B)(i) F330 Appropriate indications for antipsychotic medications
19.901 (12(B)(ii) F331 Dose reductions and behavioral intervention
19.901 (13)(B) F333 Medication errors
19.901 (12)(A) F329 Unnecessary drugs
19.901 (1)(A) F310 Therapy effect on ADLs
19.901 (6)(A) F318 Mental and psychosocial functioning
19.901 (A) F319 Appropriate treatment for mental or psychosocial adjustment
19.901 (8)(B) F324 Supervision to prevent accidents, adverse drug events
19.1301 (a)(1)(2) F406 Providing needed mental health services
19.1302 F407 Staff qualified to provide MI/MR services
19.1501 (4)(B) F429 Pharmacist reporting requirements
F505 Physician notification
ICFs/MR
M0015 90.42 (c) W124 Right to refuse treatment
M0015 90.42 (c) W128 Freedom from unnecessary drugs and physical restraints
M0015 90.42 (c) W191 Behavioral management training
M0015 90.42 (c) W192 Health care skills
M0015 90.42 (c) W193 Behavioral management skills
M0015 90.42 (c) W194 Skills to implement program plans
M0015 90.42 (c) W214 Identify behavioral management needs
M0015 90.42 (c) W262 Monitoring individual behavior programs
M0015 90.42 (c) W263 Informed consent to program
M0015 90.42 (c) W264 Monitor drug & physical restraints in behavior programs
M0015 90.42 (c) W276 Behavioral interventions
M0015 90.42 (c) W277 Hierarchy of intervention
M0015 90.42 (c) W278 Documentation of less intrusive methods
M0015 90.42 (c) W263 Informed consent to program
M0015 90.42 (c) W263 Informed consent to program
M0015 90.42 (c) W264 Monitor drug & physical restraints in behavior programs
M0015 90.42 (c) W276 Behavioral interventions
M0015 90.42 (c) W277 Hierarchy of intervention
M0015 90.42 (c) W278 Documentation of less intrusive methods
M0015 90.42 (c) W281 Use of drugs to control behavior
M0015 90.42 (c) W283 Staff who may authorize interventions
M0015 90.42 (c) W284 Monitor and control interventions
M0015 90.42 (c) W285 Safeguards for interventions
M0015 90.42 (c) W286 Protection from punishment
M0015 90.42 (c) W287 Interventions not for staff convenience
M0015 90.42 (c) W288 Interventions are not a substitute for programming
M0015 90.42 (c) W289 Interventions must be part of the program plan
M0015 90.42 (c) W290 No PRN behavior programs
M0015 90.42 (c) W310 Medication interfere with daily activities
M0015 90.42 (c) W311 Team approval of drugs for behavioral symptoms
M0015 90.42 (c) W312 Plan must aim to reduce or eliminate behavior & need for medication
M0015 90.42 (c) W313 Symptoms must justify treatment & outweigh risk of adverse effects
M0015 90.42 (c) W314 Medical & Pharmacy monitoring
M0015 90.42 (c) W315 Monitoring for therapeutic and adverse effects
M0015 90.42 (c) W316 Annual drug reduction
M0015 90.42 (c) W317 Team monitoring of medications
M0015 90.42 (c) W322 Preventive and general care
M0015 90.42 (c) W329 Physician role in initial program plan
M0015 90.42 (c) W330 Physician review and update of plan
M0025 90.42 (e)(5)(A)
M0033 90.42 (e)(7)(D)
W331 Provision of needed nursing services
M0015 90.42 (c) W361 Provision of routine and emergency drugs
M0015 90.42 (c) W362 Quarterly input from pharmacist
M0015 90.42 (c) W363 Report of irregularities to physician and team
M0015 90.42 (c) W364 Drug regimen reviews
M0015 90.42 (c) W365 Medication administration records
M0015 90.42 (c) W366 Pharmacist participation in program plan
M0015 90.42 (c) W367 Drug identification system
M0025 90.42 (e)(5)(B) W368 Drug administration and physician orders
M0015 90.42 (c) W369 Medication errors
M0032 90.42 (e)(7)(C)
M0015 90.42 (c)
W371-W373 Requirements for appropriate self-administration of medications
M0025 90.42 (e)(5)(B) W374 Drug labelling
M0015 90.42 (c) W375 Recording drug errors and adverse effects
M0015 90.42 (c) W376 Requirement to notify physician
M0015 90.42 (c) W377-W386 Requirements for appropriate drug storage
Assisted Living
92.125 (A) Right to refuse treatment
92.41(j) Medications

Top of Page Related DADS Presentations

All presentations on the Quality Matters web can only be viewed with Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.0 or later. No other browser is currently supported. However, you can follow this link to obtain the same presentations on CDROM for offline use with other browsers. Note that optimal viewing requires broadband internet access such as DSL line or cable modem. Although slow modem connections (down to 28.8 KB) are also supported, download times are much longer and the audio quality is phone-like rather than CD-quality.

Top of Page Additional Resources (including online resources)

The resources listed below are provided solely as a convenience to our users. These may include publications from government, professional, for-profit, and non-profit sources. Some of these sources may have financial ties to industry. DADS does not control the content of these resources, and the opinions and recommendations provided there are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of QAI or DADS.

Online

Appropriate Use of Psychotropic Drugs in Nursing Homes (American Family Physician)

Evaluation of Innovative Dementia Programs (an evidence-based approach)

Guidelines for Nursing Care Facilities Providing Services to Residents with Behavior Problems (Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment Health Facilities)

Internet Mental Health

Texas Medication Algorithm Project (MHMR)

In Print

Maletta G, Mattox KM, Dysken M. Guidelines for prescribing psychoactive drugs. Geriatrics 2000;55(3):65-79.

Shorr RI, Robin DW. Rational use of benzodiazepines in the elderly. Drugs & Aging 1994;4(1):9-20.

Top of Page Bibliography

[1] Ballard CG, Margallo-Lana M, Fossey J et al. A 1-year follow-up study of behavioral and psychological problems in dementia among people in care environments. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 2001;62(8):631-36.

[2] Monane M, Glynn RJ, Avorn J. The impact of sedative-hypnotic use on sleep symptoms in elderly nursing home residents. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics 1996;59(1):83-92.

[3] Ray WA, Taylor JA, Lichenstein MJ et al. Managing behavior problems in nursing home residents. Geriatric Medicine 1991;1(4):71-112.

[4] Avorn J, Soumerai SB, Everitt DE et al. A randomized trial of a program to reduce the use of psychoactive drugs in nursing homes. New England Journal of Medicine 1992;327(3):168-73.

[5] Ray WA, Taylor JA, Meador KG et al. Reducing antipsychotic drug use in nursing homes: A controlled trial of provider education. Archives of Internal Medicine 1993;153(6):713-21.

[6] Thapa PB, Meador KG, Gideon P et al. Effects of antipsychotic withdrawal in elderly nursing homes residents. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 1994;42(3):280-86.

[7] Meador KG, Taylor JA, Thapa PB et al. Predictors of antipsychotic withdrawal or dose reduction in a randomized controlled trial of provider education. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 1997;45(2):207-10.

[8] Cohen-Mansfield J, Lipson S, Werner P et al. Withdrawal of haloperidol, thioridazine, and lorazepam in the nursing home. Archives of Internal Medicine 1999;159(15):1733-40.

[9] Finkel SI, Lyons JS, Anderson RL. A Brief Agitation Rating Scale (BARS) for nursing home elderly. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 1993;41:50-52.

[10] Ventura J, Green MF, Shaner A et al. Training and quality assurance with the brief psychiatric rating scale: "The drift buster." International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research 1993;3:221-44.

[11] Cohen-Mansfield J, Marx MS, Rosenthal AS. A description of agitation in a nursing home. Journal of Gerontology 1989;44:M77-84.

[12] Campbell AJ, Robertson MC, Gardner MM et al. Psychotropic medication withdrawal and a home- based exercise program to prevent falls: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 1999;47(7):850-53.

[13] Cortés, L, Monroe, D, Morrow, K. A statewide assessment of quality of care, quality of life and consumer satisfaction in Texas Medicaid nursing facilities 2003.

Literature Review Evidence Table

Top of Page Reviewers

Peer Reviewer:
Review Date:

Top of Page Your Feedback

You may use this link to submit an anonymous evaluation of this page. DADS Quality Assurance and Improvement is interested in your comments regarding this page, whether you found it helpful, and your suggestions as to how we can make the QM Web more responsive to your needs as a provider of Long Term Care services. While we will use your ideas to improve the content of this site, please be aware that because this feedback is anonymous, QAI will not be able to respond to questions.

Any question that requires a reply should be sent to the QM Webmaster by using this link to send an email message.


Last updated: December 3, 2003
Links updated December 1, 2004
Links updated May 24, 2006
Links updated October 24, 2006